Top-Rated Charities - 2009 Archived Version
We have published a more recent list of top charities. See our most recent list.
Our criteria:
- Is there evidence that a charity's programs are effective? (Why do we look for proven programs?)
- Are a charity's programs cost-effective? (How do we use "cost-effectiveness" figures?)
- Can the charity productively use additional funds? (Why is scalability important?)
- Is the above information shared transparently?
Top-rated charities
Out of approximately 400 that we have considered, these are our top-rated charities: (What do our ratings mean?)
Charity name | Region | Focus | Evidence of effectiveness | Cost-effectiveness | Funding gap | Transparency | Monitoring and evaluation | GiveWell rating | Overall rank |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
VillageReach | International | Immunizations | Strong | Excellent | Significant | Excellent | Excellent | Three stars | 1 |
Stop TB Partnership | International | Tuberculosis | Strong | Excellent | Significant | Strong | Excellent | Three stars | 2 |
Nurse-Family Partnership | U.S. | Childcare | Strong | Limited | Probable | Above average | Excellent | Three stars | 3 |
KIPP | U.S. | Education | Above average | Limited | Probable | Above average | Strong | Three stars | 4 |
Against Malaria Foundation | International | Malaria | Moderate | Excellent | Significant | Excellent | Strong | Two stars | 5 |
Population Services International | International | HIV/AIDS; malaria | Moderate | Excellent | Probable | Excellent | Strong | Two stars | 6 |
Partners in Health | International | Health clinics | Moderate | Moderate | Probable | Above average | Above average | Two stars | 7 |
The Global Fund | International | HIV/AIDS; malaria; TB | Limited | Moderate | Probable | Excellent | Strong | Two stars | 8 |
Teach for America | U.S. | Education | Above average | Limited | Unknown | Above average | Strong | Two stars | 9 |
Pratham | India | Education | Above average | Limited | Unknown | Moderate | Strong | One star | 10 |
Interpreting our ratings
- Three stars - Strong on all of our criteria, and you can feel confident that your donation will cost-effectively change lives.
- Two stars - Stands above the vast majority of charities on our criteria, though there is substantial room for concern on at least one of the criteria.
- One star - Does not necessarily rate well on all our criteria, but there is at least one prominent and unusual factor in its favor compared to other charities: unusual transparency, unusual commitment to self-evaluation, superiority (on our criteria) to others with similar programs, and/or at least one substantial and impressive success in its past.
- 0 stars - Does not show signs of meeting any of our criteria.
What do you get for your dollar? An overview
Cause | Top-rated charities | Cost | Impact |
---|---|---|---|
International aid | VillageReach, Stop Tuberculosis Partnership | $200-$1,000 per life saved | Improve health, save lives |
Poverty (international) | None | - | Unclear, if any |
U.S. Poverty | Nurse-Family Partnership | $10,000 per child served | Increase academic performance and reduce criminal behavior |
U.S. Education | Knowledge is Power Program | $20,000 per student (including state education funds) | Improve academic performance |
Job Training (U.S.) | None | $10,000 per client served | Unclear, if any |